New Study on How to Maintain Weight Loss

Tags: , , , , , , Posted byDan Pardi on

Just in time for your “Christmas in July,” a new study published in the prestigious journal JAMA (free full text here) tells us how to maintain weight loss by supporting our energy expenditure in a healthy way. As many people can attest, (temporarily) losing weight can seem easier than maintaining that weight loss. This is because the body acclimates to weight loss by reducing its energy expenditure (kinda like conserving water in times of drought). This new study looked at how different types of diets affect energy expenditure after a period of weight loss. So, let’s get into the details.

 

The new study on how to maintain weight loss

What did they do? They recruited 21 folks who were overweight or obese(mean BMI of 34.4) and between 18-40 years old. They had them go through a 4 week baseline period followed by a 12 week weight loss program to achieve at least a 10% weight loss. Following the weight loss, there was 4 week weight stabilization period before participants tried three types of diets that were matched on caloric content for four weeks each in a randomized order. The main outcome measure was resting energy expenditure, with secondary measures of total energy expenditure, hormone levels, and metabolic markers.

So what did these three maintenance diets look like? The three diets included a low-fat diet (what most people will tell you to eat – whole grains and lean meats); a low glycemic index diet (avoiding foods that spike blood sugar levels and insulin release); and a very low carbohydrate diet.

Second, what happened to all of the markers that we might worry about when one is eating the very low carb diet that is high in saturated fat and cholesterol and low in fiber? Well, the results below show that insulin sensitivity was best on the very low carb diet, HDL (good) cholesterol was best on the very low carb diet, triglycerides were best on the very low carb diet, and systolic blood pressure was not best, but markedly improved relative to pre-weight loss on the very low carb diet. So far, so good…

But of course, nothing is perfect and the authors note that C-reactive protein (a marker of inflammation) tended to be higher with the very low carb diet and urinary cortisol (a marker of stress) was higher on the very low carb diet. Nonetheless, leptin levels were quite improved and the authors note that participant ratings of hunger and well-being did not differ between the three diets.

So, what do we take away from this? This study has several strengths in that it included an initial weight loss phase with baseline assessments, the presentation of the diets was randomized, and the study used a crossover or within-subjects design so each person could serve as his/her own control. However, there are also several limitations, which include the relatively small sample size (N=21) and the relatively short duration of the test diets (4 weeks). It would be interesting to see longer-term results in a larger sample of people, but it is also always easier to design a perfect study than to conduct one.

 

How to maintain weight loss: conclusions

As for the conclusions regarding how to maintain weight loss, we’ll leave it to the authors:

“In conclusion, our study demonstrates that

  • commonly consumed diets can affect metabolism and components of the metabolic syndrome in markedly different ways during weight loss maintenance, independent of energy content.
  • The low-fat diet produced changes in energy expenditure and serum leptin that would predict weight regain. In addition, this conventionally recommended diet had unfavorable effects on most of the metabolic syndrome components studied herein.
  • In contrast, the very low carbohydrate diet had the most beneficial effects on energy expenditure and several metabolic syndrome components, but this restrictive regimen may increase cortisol excretion and CRP.
  • The low–glycemic index diet appears to have qualitatively similar, although smaller, metabolic benefits to the very low-carbohydrate diet, possibly without the deleterious effects on physiological stress and chronic inflammation.
  • These findings suggest that a strategy to reduce glycemic load rather than dietary fat may be advantageous for weight-loss maintenance and cardiovascular disease prevention.
  • Ultimately, successful weight-loss maintenance will require behavioral and environmental interventions to facilitate long-term dietary adherence.”

Cheers to these authors for a really great and important study.

Have a Happy (and safe) Fourth of July folks!

Published by Dan Pardi

is passionate about food, movement, and sleep. Interested in developing low-cost, high value health solutions. Also interested in anthropology, evolutionary biology, exercise and inactivity physiology, cognition, neuroeconomics, decision making, circadian biology, epistemology, gastronomy, food culture and politics, agriculture, sustainable practices, and dogs. Activities include mountain biking, CrossFit, hiking, dancing, and long walks with my headphones.

Go Pro

Categories

GET OUR ARTICLES!

Signup to get notified about every new post!

Members

Featured Articles

Why Walnuts May Help You Stay Lean

Why Walnuts May Help You Stay Lean

Walnuts are a dietary paradox – or at least they appear that way. As you probably know, walnuts are very calorically dense, mainly because of their fat content. Just one ounce of walnuts – that is about 12-14 halves – contains 185 calories. If you’ve ever tracked your food intake, you know that sort of thing can add up very quickly, especially if you’re just grabbing handfuls and not measuring.

But if we take a look at the literature, we plainly see that people who eat nuts are actually less likely to gain weight, and long term consumption of nuts is associated with reduced risk of obesity.

So why are nuts such an outlier?

Some have pointed to inefficient energy absorption. But other studies of nuts suggest another mechanism may be at play. Research suggests that when people eat nuts, they wind up compensating for most of the calories by eating less of other foods – without even trying.

Researchers affiliated with Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center decided to look inside the brain to figure out what exactly was going on here. They compared people who ate a walnut-based smoothie to counterparts consuming a placebo smoothie, and the results are revealing. Check out the blog to find out what they discovered!

Exercise and Cognitive Function: Get Smarter Right Now?

Exercise and Cognitive Function: Get Smarter Right Now?

It was traditionally thought that total brain blood flow was not changed during physical activity. Research in the last 10 years, however, changed this perspective. We now understand that the increased neuronal and metabolic activity of the brain during exercise drive increases in blood flow to it. We have also learned that exercise that is too intense will reduce blood flow and oxygen delivery causing fatigue. So, what is the ideal intensity to stimulate blood flow to the brain, and perhaps, augment your mental abilities in the moment?

Can Dark Chocolate Help You Get Fit?

Can Dark Chocolate Help You Get Fit?

When we think of foods that improve athletic performance, chocolate is maybe not one of the first options that comes to mind.

We’ve known for a while that certain molecules found in chocolate, known as flavonols, are associated with health benefits to the heart and the brain. Epicatechin, in particular, has exhibited widespread effects throughout the body.

But some emerging evidence suggests that chocolate may also aid in exercise performance – weird as it may sound.

Here’s what the research says so far, and how it seems to work.

What Is the Best Time to Eat? Diet and Circadian Rhythms

What Is the Best Time to Eat? Diet and Circadian Rhythms

Around this time of year, much of the world is advancing their clocks by one hour to make efficient use of seasonal daylight. Americans switched to Daylight Savings Time last week, and this week Europeans will revert to Summer Time.

When this happens, we all “lose” an hour of sleep, because we have to get up and get things done an hour earlier than we have been. This is in relation not just to the light and dark cycles of the day, but also to our body clocks.

One hour sounds like a small change, but it can make a big difference in how we function, at least in the short term. For example, data from the past two decades shows that there is a statistically significant spike in the number of car wrecks on the Monday immediately following the shift to Daylight Savings Time in the US.

As we all adjust to the time change, it’s worthwhile to consider how other aspects of our lives can sway our circadian rhythms. Circadian clocks govern the rhythms of sleep and activity in virtually all animals and are responsive to a variety of stimuli like light and stress. Research is starting to suggest that our eating patterns – specifically when we eat – can also have a pervasive impact.

Sleep Is Critical for Learning. Podcast with Professor Marcos Frank

Sleep Is Critical for Learning. Podcast with Professor Marcos Frank

We do not enter into the world with infinite knowledge of ourselves and our surroundings. We don’t have knowledge or skill to survive, to dance, or to do martial arts with grace and efficiency. We don’t know enough about ourselves or know how to interact best with different types of people we encounter. We don’t know how to accelerate our ability to get better at something. We are born, however, with the capacity to learn and to remember, and by virtue of this skill, we have an incredible potential to do great things.

Professor Marcos FrankToday, important stuff happened to you. Tonight, when you sleep, your brain will extend the process of turning that stimulation – the sites, sounds, thoughts, emotions, facts, etc. – into memories that you can access at a moments notice in the future. It’s amazing when you think about it: experiences, facts, skills, and even thought patterns become a part of who we are. How much do you know now that you didn’t know 1o to 15 years ago, or even last week, last month, or yesterday? The process of accumulating information, and accessing when needed, is so routine it’s easy to forget that something is going to make it possible. As it turns out, sleep plays a vital role in the formation of certain types of memories. In this interview, I speak with someone who has made, and continues to make, significant contributions to help the world better understand how all this magic works. My guest is Marcos Frank, Ph.D., who is the Interim Chair of the Department of Biomedical Sciences in the Elson S. Floyd College of Medicine at Washington State University. I hope you enjoy this discussion as much as I did.

Featured Products

Contributors